31 Years of Reviews:
2007: "An important reissue offers the excellent 1988 performances of Beethoven's piano concertos by Steven Lubin and the Academy of Ancient Music…Lubin plays not only spiritedly, but powerfully." Paul Turok, Turok's Choice
'06: "The interpretations are fast, lean, and incisive…, yet always governed by shapely, flexible phrasing…" [review of Decca Beethoven Concerto-cycle reissue] Jed Distler, Gramophone
'05: "The playing is sharply etched and ruthlessly good."
[Newly released recording of Mozart's Piano Concertos K.449 and K.467] Robert Strobl, Toccata (Germany)
'04: "Blisteringly virtuosic." Neville Cohn, The West Australian (Perth, Australia)
'03: "He played in a manner reminiscent of Canadian wonder Glenn Gould." [Bach 5th Brandenburg, Youngstown Symphony] Robert Rollin, Youngstown Vindicator
'02: "Lubin's performance takes the breath away." Kitty Montgomery, Daily Freeman
'01: "Steven Lubin's affinity for the subtle pallette of the fortepiano has made him one of the leading specialists in the instrument. His secure, sensitive playing provided a strong foundation for the animated performance." Tim Smith, Baltimore Sun
'00: "He brought out all the glory of Beethoven and Chopin." Joseph McClellan, Washington Post
'99: "Steven Lubin's incredible subtlety of timbre and registration has never been equalled." Vincent Agrech, Diapason, France
'98: "With a spirit of fresh adventure he thundered through the rolling octaves and colossal chords that link this work [Prokofiev 1 st Concerto, with the Odessa Philharmonic] with its great predecessor, Tchaikovsky's 1st Concerto." Jennifer Weininger, Worcester Sunday Telegram
'97: "Lubin astonishes in Mendelssohn—yesterday's listeners heard an impassioned Mendelssohn [Concertgebouw, Amsterdam].the altogether raging energy of the music-making, the sheer joy in playing, overwhelmed the listeners." Ernst Vermeulen, NRC Handelsblad, Amsterdam
'96: "The debut concert of his current Spanish tour.could not have been a happier beginning. He played with a captivating liveliness and brilliance, and totally dazzled his listeners." Juan Angel Vela del Campo, El Pais, Spain
'95: "Accomplished and adroit keyboard artistry came to San Juan last Wednesday night in the person of Steven Lubin. He conferred on Beethoven the same agitato intensity and interest in athletic digital technique that had distinguished his Haydn." Mark Staebler, San Juan Star , Puerto Rico
'94: "Steven Lubin, one of the world's leading performers on the fortepiano, was the soloist at the Meyerson Symphony Center.[and] justified his exalted reputation. He dived to the heart of the music's drama." Lawson Taitte, Dallas Morning News
'93: "Lubin was a guest artist at the International Espoo Piano Festival and his concert was extraordinarily fine—he showed himself to be a musician to his very fingertips." Mikael Kosk, Hufvudstadbladet, Finland
'92: "An exceptionally satisfying recital.by a seasoned professional who presents the music with secure technique and a directness of rhythm and phraseology. With Chopin's B-minor Sonata Lubin confirmed that he is not a period-instrument practitioner by default. He possesses the technique to do justice to the most demanding 19th-century literature." Herbert Glass, The Los Angeles Times
'91:"Steven Lubin proved to be not only a great pianist, but a Mozart interpreter of genius, one of the finest before the public today." Eric de Gaudemar, Le Méridionale, France
'90: "Steven Lubin proved an excellent soloist and partner in Mozart's Piano Concerto No.20 [with the Mozarteum Orchestra of Salzburg]. A virtuoso of the highest order, he strove for crystalline clarity of tone and line." Daniel Buckley, Tucson Citizen
'89: "Lubin is a splendid pianist, a virtuoso of the keyboard." Giovanni Toffano, Il Mattino, Padua
'88: "Steven Lubin, the fortepiano soloist in Mozart's Piano Concerto No. 24, played with poetry and sensitivity and offered a dazzling cadenza." Allan Kozinn, The New York Times
'87: "Many listeners think of Beethoven's First Piano Concerto as the dawning of the new romantic era, and keyboardist Steven Lubin suggested just that [Ravinia Festival]. This was a First Concerto of remarkable imagination, wit and lyrical grace." Howard Reich, Chicago Tribune
'86: "Lubin is a complete master of his instrument, commands the imagination to enliven Mozart's ideas, and possesses the musical intellect to perceive and render the inner architecture of each movement." Richard Perry, The Whig-Standard, Ontario
'85: "Steven Lubin is the brilliant soloist—his technical and artistic capabilities appear to be utterly limitless." Alte Musik aktuell, Germany
'84: "A particularly graceful musician. It seems a simple thing to make listeners hear precisely where phrases begin and end, but many performers cannot, and few do it as well as this one." Bernard Holland, The New York Times
'83: "Lubin has an unconventionally unified and contemplative concept of this extraordinary work [Mussorgsky's Pictures at an Exhibition ] and the technical equipment to set it out effectively." John D. Wiser, Woodstock Times
'82: "Above all there was the fortepiano, played by Steven Lubin, who is the guiding spirit behind the Mozartean Players and a leader in the fortepiano revival. The result was fascinating to hear. Mr. Lubin's playing justified the fortepiano not through its sound alone, but through the artistry that he brought to his interpretation." John Rockwell, The New York Times
'81: "Perhaps this country's leading exponent of the fortepiano." Bill Zakariasen, New York Daily News
'80: "One of the fortepiano's better solo exponents. Mr. Lubin showed how subtly, colorfully and convincingly a work such as the Mozart sonata could be played on something other than a modern concert grand." Raymond Ericson, The New York Times
'79: "He played with exhilarating fluency." Donal Henahan, The New York Times
'78: "The evening made a powerful impression upon an audience accustomed to modern instruments, and they responded with prolonged applause." Erna Schwerin, Mozarteum Proceedings, Salzburg
'77 : "He played with warmth and virtuosity." [Debut, Carnegie Recital Hall]. Allan Kozinn, Music Journal
Beethoven Concerto Cycle Reviews:
L'Oiseau-Lyre [Decca] 421 408-2, three CDs, with Christopher Hogwood and the Academy of Ancient Music
Excerpts from some of the favorable reviews garnered, worldwide:
What a joy, this Beethoven cycle—a godsend for the performance-practice partisan that merits comparison even
to modern-instrument mainstays like Fleisher and Kempff. Lubin's playing of four different fortepianos
is mature and imaginative.
David Claris, Fanfare
Steven Lubin, a renowned fortepiano specialist, seeks to convince, never to shock. His playing, technically
very assured, is of a clarity and transparency to which we are not at all accustomed in this repertoire.
He possesses the fluidity and grace that suit the earlier concertos so well, but he also knows how to wax
ardent and combative in the two mature masterworks. Lubin possesses a singing line of remarkable profundity.
The adagio of the Fifth Concerto, as well as that of the Third, are voluptuously poetic. Despite a respect
for the letter, the spirit is very much a presence. All of Beethoven is in evidence here, with its gripping
contrasts and its play of shadow and light.
Francis Albou, Répertoire [France]
Steven Lubin provides miraculous solo playing on four different fortepianos to mark different stages of
development during Beeethoven's life. It can be easily recommended as the best recording of the Beethoven
concertos in the catalog.
Jonathan Richmond, The Tech [MIT]
Steven Lubin's playing is beautiful, clean, precise, graceful and yet resolute, and he achieves moments of
profound intensity, as in the Adagio of the Emperor.
Laura Poli, Musica [Italy]
The just-released recording of the five Beethoven Piano Concertos results from a collaboration between the
American pianist Steven Lubin and the Academy of Ancient Music, directed by Christopher Hogwood—and it is in
fact phenomenal. A virtuoso soloist playing four different copies of Viennese pianos loses none of the
specialness of each—he draws out all the instruments' finest nuances, without ever thereby losing the forest
for the trees.
If we play the concertos in the order in which they were composed, we do sense a 'growth' in the form, and
Beethoven's mastery of it; but the playing style varies appropriately, so that the parts of this series are as
interesting as the whole. Most of the tempos seem just about right, and the pacing of movements are
thoroughly convincing. The technical standards are high: the solo playing is virtually flawless, the
orchestral articulation very clean.
William Drabkin, Early Music
The set is an arresting, controversial experience. Lubin's pianism is extremely cultivated, and Hogwood
stresses clarity and rhythmic verve.
Allan Ulrich, San Francisco Examiner
You'd better listen. These recordings challenge the status quo as much as or more than previous efforts of
this kind. It is almost as if the early-instrument approach permits the musicians to be forthright and
lyrical, and full-blooded and dramatic, without having to be either eccentric or academic. The real proof
is in the pudding. And what a pudding! What matters is that the sound is right, and so are the tempos,
the phrasing, the larger architecture, the drama.
Eric Salzman, Stereo Review
The Lubin/Hogwood set is not only the first complete series of these pieces on period instruments but also,
I think, a set of great performances.
Leslie Gerber, Fanfare
Lubin achieves an extraordinary color range in the solo parts, within the seeming limitations of nuance of
the historic pianos, and elicits from each instrument its maximum of tonal charm. It is generally
astonishing how all the painstaking scholarly research for this project in no way diminishes its artistic
impact. The recordings burst with vitality, and are as unlike bloodless academic test-tube samples as they
could possibly be.
Joseph Oehrlein, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung [Germany]
The whole performance has plenty of vitality. Lubin has many sensitive details of timing, shaping the music
attentively, sometimes pushing urgently towards a cadence: all very aptly tuned to the vigorous, fiery young
Beethoven.There is a lot of tension in Lubin's playing, with a certain amount of holding back and pressing
forward as his view of the musical sense demands; the effect is of a large-scale performance, of the kind
that keeps one on the edge of one's seat. Perhaps closer to what Beethoven heard in his imagination than
anything recorded before.
Stanley Sadie, Gramophone [England]
Here is a very bold step into little charted waters. Lubin uses four different pianos: I like best the
pungent piano in the bustling First Concerto, and the sturdy one used for the Emperor, which attains a
steely eloquence in the slow movement. These are no-nonsense readings, sharp-edged and often very exciting.
Nicholas Kenyon, The Observer [England]
With the release of all Beethoven's piano concertos played on historical instruments, it is clear that some
kind of milestone has been reached in the early music movement. Mr. Lubin plays with full conviction; he knows
how to build a climax, to "take it away" toward the end of a cadenza, to underline a crucial point. This is
a set everyone interested in the Beethoven concertos should have, fascinating for what it adumbrates and
satisfying for what it achieves.
Will Crutchfield, The New York Times
The performances are excellent. I suspect that many listeners will prefer Lubin/Hogwood to all others in this
highly competitive field.
Joseph McClellan, The Washington Post
Lubin uses the extra clarity of the fortepiano very tellingly and, though speeds are on the brisk side, he
is never extreme, and slow movements are allowed to breathe and find poetry and repose. Hogwood accompanies
with freshness and resilience, and the recording is attractively vivid.
Edward Greenfield, The New Penguin Guide [England]
For the listener who has heard the Beethoven concertos played only on modern pianos, any one of Lubin's
realizations is startling enough to make it seem as though the concerto is being heard for the first time.
From the standpoint of technique and musicianship.Lubin's [are] shapely, animated, and always brilliantly
James Wierzbicki, Musical America
Lubin's pianism has a freewheeling joie-de-vivre that serves to inspire conductor Hogwood. Lubin is deeply
concerned with phrasing and shaping, and that concern makes his performances eminently worthwhile.
Harris Goldsmith, Musical America
Lubin proves adept at drawing contrasts and building them in varied and interesting ways. Lubin's special
insight and imagination and intense lyricism [contribute to] the success of his venture.
Jonathan Richmond, Christian Science Monitor
Authenticity in the narrowest sense is not the primary issue here. There is no attempt to produce a precious
or quaint sound; on the contrary these pieces are bold and spacious in their interpretation. This is a very
welcome and definitive performance. There is no doubt among several reviewers that this set will become the
standard against which all future authentic instrument performances will be compared; with these recordings
in your collection, you really will not need a "modern"-instrument version at all.
Jim Pollard, The Blue Note
Steven Lubin uses four different instruments for the five concertos, and readily justifies that in the
development and expansion from no.2 (the first written) through to the Emperor. The articulation of
passagework is sparklingly clear in a way virtually impossible on a modern Steinway. Slow movements have
the lyrical poetry and repose one needs. Even in the hushed question and answer of recitative at the end
of the Adagio of no.2, with its amazing anticipation of Beethoven's last period, Lubin conveys on his
light-toned instrument the necessary weight and gravity. In no.3 Beethoven's own big cadenza for the first
movement comes out marvellously well, with the flurries of figuration in their new clarity more than usually
conveying the flavour of what a Beethoven improvisation must have really been like.
Edward Greenfield, The Guardian [England]
If these recordings become the standard period instrument performance of Beethoven's piano concertos, it
will not simply be because this is the first complete cycle available on CD. Steven Lubin does not merely
play Beethoven on the fortepiano. He transforms the instrument from a quaint antique into a powerful and
intriguingly individual musical voice. It is Lubin's command of each musical moment that contributes the
decisive human dimension to the impact of his instrument's distinctive sonorities. This inspired
collaboration between Lubin and Hogwood's Academy of Ancient Music stands impressively on its own as a
legitimate and substantial interpretation of Beethoven's great cycle of concertos. With this set in your
library you really don't need a "modern" version. All of the expressive shading is here, and all of the
sweeping dynamics too. It's the real thing.
Tom Vernier, Digital Audio & Compact Disc Review
Less than twenty years for a cascade of revolutions that takes us from the classical Mozartean mold to the
titanic daring of the "Emperor!" It is just this individuality that the complete Lubin-Hogwood edition
succeeds in restoring to each of these pages. It is aided in this by the pianist's choice of instruments;
he demonstrates decisively to what extent the master's writing was a consequence of instrumental innovations.
This would not suffice to cause a stir, however, if it were not supported by a liberty of playing and phrasing,
a search for supple and free sonorities that recreate a delightful spirit of surprise and a sense of improvisation.
Serge Martin, Diapason [France]
There is plenty of personality in these performances, particularly from the pianist. Any set that gives us
such excellent performances, so well recorded, and provides us the opportunity to hear old music with new ears
deserves a strong recommendation. I'm especially glad that the worthy playing of Lubin, a superb artist,
will be getting this wide exposure.
Leslie Gerber, Fanfare
I'll not give up any of the great sets of the past: Schnabel/Sargent, Fleischer/Szell, Kempff, or the various
recordings by Curzon, Gould, and the like. But this one will certainly take a place of honor with them.
Though I find all of the performances entrancing, the passion which Lubin brings to the Third is especially
attractive. In the Emperor we find the whole emerging with a new-minted splendor. One can imagine how
boldly original this music must have sounded in 1809 when originally heard!
John Bauman, American Record Guide
Listening to these discs, one realizes how this work has been accomplished without a trace of pedantry.
The performances are, from all perspectives, truly exemplary: Lubin and Hogwood have reached a level, in
the care with which they phrase, in the quality of the sounds they produce, in the pure beauty of the
music-making, that would be awfully hard to surpass.
Fernando de Carli, Compact Disc [Italy]